The Truth They Didn't Teach Us: How Racism Helped Kill Universal Healthcare in America

A Missed Moment in History

In 1945, President Harry S. Truman made a bold move.
He proposed a national health insurance plan that would cover every American, rich or poor, Black or white, urban or rural. It would be paid for by a simple payroll tax: $1 per worker, $1 per employer.

It was called the Wagner–Murray–Dingell Bill.
And it could’ve changed everything.

But it failed.
Not because it was unaffordable.
Not because Americans didn’t want it.

It failed because racism said no.

The Wall of Resistance: Dixiecrats and the AMA

Two major forces united against Truman’s plan:

1. The American Medical Association (AMA) called it “socialized medicine” and feared losing control over healthcare practices.

2. Southern Democrats, often called Dixiecrats, who didn’t fear socialism nearly as much as they feared integration.

They knew that a federally run healthcare system would require hospitals to serve all Americans equally.

And for them, that was a deal-breaker.

“Black People in White Hospitals?”

Southern lawmakers openly worried that national healthcare would erode Jim Crow.
They didn’t want Black patients sharing beds, doctors, or wards with white ones.

So they killed the bill.
Not with loud protests, but with quiet obstruction.

The same kind of silence that keeps systems of oppression alive.

Medicare: The Quiet Revolution

In 1965, President Lyndon B. Johnson signed Medicare into law.

And here's the part they don’t often teach:

Hospitals had to desegregate to receive Medicare funding.

Dr. Philip Lee, then assistant secretary of health, said it clearly:

“No integration? No money.”

Within a year, 95% of American hospitals were integrated.

Not because of a sudden moral awakening; 
But because their funding depended on it.

The Words of Dr. King

Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. saw this clearly. He famously said:

“Of all the forms of inequality, injustice in healthcare is the most shocking and inhuman.”

That quote wasn’t just poetic.
It was prophetic.

Because to this day, Black Americans are still dying younger, still being denied care, still navigating a healthcare system designed without us in mind.

Why This Matters Now

Understanding this history helps us understand the present:

• Why the U.S. still doesn’t have universal healthcare

• Why Black maternal mortality remains so high

• Why access to care is still based on zip code and skin color

This wasn’t an accident.
It was a strategy.
A racist strategy dressed up in economic rhetoric.

Let’s Unlearn the Lie

The next time someone says, “We just can’t afford healthcare for all,”
ask them: Who is ‘we’? And who gets left out when we say that?

Because universal healthcare was never just about policy.

It was about power.
It was about who gets to live well, and who doesn’t. 

Remember This:

Universal healthcare failed not because America lacked money; 
But because too many lawmakers lacked the moral courage to share it with Black lives.

Let’s Keep the Conversation Going

🖤 Share this post
🖤 Tag a friend
🖤 Use your voice to rewrite the narrative

Follow me at @bina_ayesha_banks
Explore more through @proseandink
Read, rise, and rest well at www.binaayesha.com